01
Amica Mutual
Consistently top-ranked for customer satisfaction, Amica is a direct insurer with dividend policies that return money to policyholders and industry-leading claims handling.
▲ Steady·Score +18
Auto Insurance
Best Auto Insurance Companies for Every Driver
Compare the top car insurance providers offering the best rates, coverage options, and customer satisfaction ratings to keep you protected on the road.
Pick your favorites · Every vote moves the ranking · Results update live
02
Erie Insurance
An underrated gem offering exceptional value with rate lock feature preventing premium increases after claims, and outstanding regional customer service in available states.
▲ Steady·Score +18
03
Root Insurance
A tech-forward insurer that bases premiums entirely on your actual driving behavior through a smartphone test drive — potentially saving good drivers up to 52% vs traditional insurers.
▲ Steady·Score +13
04
Travelers Insurance
A top-tier insurer with strong financial stability offering competitive rates, discounts for hybrid/electric vehicles, and excellent coverage customization for any driver profile.
▲ Steady·Score +12
05
GEICO
Famous for its 'save 15%' promise, GEICO delivers consistently low premiums, a highly rated mobile app, and fast claims processing — ideal for budget-conscious drivers seeking quality coverage.
▲ Steady·Score +11
06
Progressive
A leader in usage-based insurance with the Snapshot program that rewards safe drivers with discounts. Offers competitive rates and the Name Your Price tool to match any budget.
▲ Steady·Score +10
07
Farmers Insurance
Known for its Signal app that monitors driving behavior for discounts. Farmers provides comprehensive coverage bundles and multi-policy discounts for home and auto bundling.
▲ Steady·Score +8
08
A
Allstate
Comprehensive coverage with unique features like safe driving bonuses, claim-free rewards, and the Drivewise app that tracks habits to earn additional premium discounts.
▲ Steady·Score +7
09
Nationwide
Strong coverage options including gap insurance, accident forgiveness, and vanishing deductibles that decrease each year you remain claim-free — rewarding loyal, safe drivers.
▲ Steady·Score +3
10
Liberty Mutual
Unique add-ons including better car replacement and new car replacement coverage, accident forgiveness, and a 24/7 claims service with excellent mobile app support.
Be first to vote ↑
11
USAA
Consistently rated the highest in customer satisfaction, USAA offers outstanding coverage and rates exclusively to military members, veterans, and their families. Simply the best for those who qualify.
▲ Steady·Score -1
12
State Farm
America's largest auto insurer known for its extensive agent network, competitive rates, and strong claims satisfaction. Offers accident forgiveness, Drive Safe & Save discounts, and outstanding support.
▲ Steady·Score -2
Predict the rank
“Amica Mutual”
Currently ranked #1. Where will it be in 7 days?